Concepts

Subscribe to posts

Independence and self-development

posted Feb 2, 2012, 11:54 AM by Maxymets Serhiy   [ updated Feb 2, 2012, 11:56 AM ]

Status: dream

As far, as TRYNE prooves itself to be the best source of  effective decisions, tasks become more and more serious. One day the price of the question will make TRYNE company to falsify the decision. Thats why TRYNE should not belong to anyone.

There is the point, where the first part of project is over. Point, where TRYNE starts to make decisions about itself, where it doesn't need external development efforts anymore. It will pass the decisions about itself directly to Executive Team. Here's the whole scheme:

TRYNE relations scheme

Sure, this infographic is a mess and everything is no more then projections.

Solution Tree

posted Feb 2, 2012, 7:52 AM by Maxymets Serhiy   [ updated Feb 2, 2012, 10:07 AM ]

Status: live at Prototype 3 
Remark: self-organization not implemented yet

Solution Tree is a tool for solving tasks, that are too complex for one person or limited team. It is based on steps.

Step - a small theoretical or practical move in direction of solution (according to someone's idea), being submitted in written form.

Every participant may submit it's own starting step or step next to someone else's step:

Solution Tree

Bad steps are removed, solutions are confirmed via Unmoderated self-organization. The power of this concept grows with the number of participants. Solution Tree can be build up rapidly, single person may just drop the seed of idea and it will be developed to solid solution by other participants.

Facts arguing

posted Feb 2, 2012, 6:57 AM by Maxymets Serhiy   [ updated Feb 2, 2012, 10:06 AM ]

Status: live at Prototype 3

There is no ability to argue your vision without affecting someone mind. This harms opinion independance and diversity, and this is critical for Basic decision-making.

The only way to influence the result (except submitting nice decisions) is to expose some not well known facts to the judging public. Facts use scheme similar to decisions:

Facts arguing scheme

Here is a scenario (that steps are executed simultaneously with Basic decision-making steps):
  1. Everyone have the ability to submit a fact to Decision Pool. 
  2. False, bad and duplicate facts are processed via  Unmoderated self-organization. 
  3. Every fact is rated as important one by some % of participants.
  4. Top-rated facts form the Important facts group (up to 5 positions  usually).
  5. Important facts are shown to every participant before any judgements around current task.

Basic decision-making

posted Feb 2, 2012, 6:30 AM by Maxymets Serhiy   [ updated Feb 2, 2012, 10:06 AM ]

Status: live at Prototype 3

This concept is not big novelty, but it contains some modifications for high-load. This scheme performs well even with millions of  participants and thousands of decision variants.

Decision making concept

The main principle: participant should not see any voting results up to his final vote in order to stay independent-minded. According to The Wisdom of Crowds researches, the quality of final decision depends on opinions independence and diversity.

Here is a scenario (take a note, that steps are executed simultaneously):
  1. Everyone have the ability to submit his decision variant to Decision Pool. 
  2. Bad and duplicate decisions are processed via  Unmoderated self-organization. 
  3. Every decision is rated as probable one by some % of participants.
  4. High-rated decisions form the Decision Top (up to 5 positions  usually).
  5. Participants perform final vote at Decision Top (shown in random order).
  6. If the decision with big advantage is detected, it is marked as Taken Decision.
  7. Process continues, while Taken Decision appears.
Sure, this contept is not perfect one and there are a lot of questions to it. But it's good starting point. By the way it can be considered as consensus friendly decision-making, especially being combined with other TRYNE concepts.

Unmoderated self-organization

posted Feb 2, 2012, 5:34 AM by Maxymets Serhiy   [ updated Feb 2, 2012, 10:08 AM ]

Status: live at Prototype 3

Most contemporary data systems are moderated by owners or some selected volunteers. This arrangement gives certain power in hands of some individuals. They get the ability to influence the process.

As opposite, TRYNE uses unmoderated self-organization. Every aspect of system data is judged by some percent of randomly selected visitors. If they confirm some problems, the corresponding action is taken automatically:

Sanation principle

At any page transition system may show visitor a question, and he needs to answer it to proceed further. This is everyone's contribution to TRYNE contents.

1-5 of 5